1992 | 2hr | Comedy Crime | Rated 15 | Dir. Jonathan Lynn
With a second lockdown hitting the UK at the time of writing there is likely a demand for more uplifting entertainment as citizens battle with cabin fever. Looking for a feel good romp revisited a classic in my household, the 1992 comedy My Cousin Vinny. Pleasantly surprised by how well it holds up, I decided to sing its praises as an overlooked hidden gem that would go over extremely well at any family/flatmate movie night readers might be planning.
Set in Alabama innocent road trippers, Billy (Ralph Maccio) and Stan (Mitchell Whitfield), find themselves on trial for murder when a convenience store they stopped at becomes the scene of a grisly crime. Enter Vinny (Joe Pesci), a personal injury lawyer and cousin of Billy, and Vinny’s fiancee Mona (Marisa Tomei). Vinny is tasked with clearing Billy and Stan’s names despite only recently passing the bar (after six attempts) and never having taken a case to trial.
The film, strangely enough, has garnered a cult status from lawyers and legal professionals, mainly due to its authenticity and legal accuracy. My Cousin Vinny takes full advantage of the authenticity of its courtroom proceedings and even subverts typical tropes of the genre that often make legal professionals cringe. The pre-trial hearings begin and Vinny attempts to protest the innocence of his clients. The judge interrupts this moment to point out that this part of the process only involves stating the defendant's plea: ‘Guilty’ or ‘not guilty’. Vinny pushes the issue, hoping to establish as early as possible that the two young men are the victims of a misunderstanding but the judge won’t hear it. Vinny’s poor understanding of actual court proceedings lands him in big trouble and sets off a running joke that Vinny keeps landing himself in prison in contempt of court.
Similarly, midway through the film Vinny attempts to ‘finesse’ the prosecuting lawyer, hoping to gain access to his files and witnesses. He’s shocked when the attorney is easily manipulated and has his secretary fax Vinny all the files and witness information. Thinking he’s a silver tongued devil he boasts this to Mona who has been studying the Alabama Court Conduct book they’ve been given. She correctly points out to Vinny that he didn’t do anything special and by law the prosecutor has to hand over all of his files and arguments. Real courts simply don’t run on shocking surprises and legal mind games, much to Vinny’s surprise. “What? They didn’t teach that in law school?” Shouts a condescending Mona to an embarrassed Vinny.
However for all of the commitment to legal accuracy the film never pulls any comedic punches. The film effortlessly glides through comedic interchanges with more endlessly quotable lines than you can shake a stick at. Whether it's seeing Vinny and Mona adjusting to country life, unable to get a good night's sleep, Vinny constantly talking his way out of trouble by the skin of his teeth or watching Vinny struggle to grasp court etiquette. There is a non stop flow of gags and comedic setpieces that don’t disappoint.
While the film is populated with great side characters, Fred Gwyne’s performance as The Judge being a personal favourite, the film is really carried by the central couple of Vinny and Mona. Their comedic chemistry is masterful and there’s enough energy in each scene they share to potentially fuel their own spin off sitcom. Tomei even managed to nab an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress for her performance, the film's only nomination.
Deserved of it’s cult comedy status, My Cousin Vinny is certainly one to spend a comfortable afternoon with. It’s hard to not feel thrilled when Vinny and Mona pull a final trick from their proverbial sleeve and save the day, just when all seems hopeless. Guaranteed to deliver good vibes and satisfy any aged audiences.
- Ethan Lamb















